Green Desktop Infrastructure

White Paper
Green Desktop Infrastructure
An Approach to Reduce Desktop Carbon Footprint
The proliferation of desktops is increasingly
contributing to carbon emissions, through inefficient
power consumption, heat generation and subsequent
cooling requirements. Desktops have long been
ignored from strategic IT efficiency and optimization
initiatives. Traditional ‘Green’ initiatives are no longer
effective in addressing massive carbon emissions.
There is a need to adopt alternative and pathbreaking approaches to leverage diminishing natural
resources, control rising costs, and go ‘GREEN’.
This paper provides an insight into the need for
Green Desktops and a transformational solution
and reference architecture for implementing a
‘future-ready’ cloud-enabled Green Desktop
Computing framework.
About the Author
Ankur Srivastava
Ankur Srivastava is a Solution Architect working with the Hi-Tech
Industry Solution Unit (ISU) of TCS and currently leads the TCS
NetApp Solutions Lab. His main areas of focus are Storage,
Database and Virtualization. He has close to eight years of
experience as a technologist, delivering solutions across
technology stacks covering storage, servers, databases and
applications.
Ankur holds a Bachelor of Technology (B. Tech) degree in
Computer Science and Engineering and is also a NetApp Certified
Implementation Engineer (NCIE).
2
Table of Contents
1.
Introduction
4
2.
Traditional Green Desktops
4
3.
Introduction
4
Approach Analysis
4
Approach Evolution
5
Green Desktop Infrastructure
5
Introduction
5
Approach Analysis
5
Reference Architecture
6
Test Results & Business Benefits
8
4.
Conclusion
13
5.
References
13
3
Introduction
With compelling growth opportunities and rapid expansion plans, organizations today are considering
mergers and acquisitions to improve time-to-market. These have resulted in rapid changes in employee
numbers, leading to proliferation of desktops to address business objectives. These desktops are mostly
procured on demand forecast and have very limited prior architectural or deployment planning. This
results in distributed desktop silos with increasing power and energy demands.
Desktop computers have an average useful lifespan of three to four years after which technology
evolution renders them unusable or inefficient. These then need to be replaced with new desktops to
match the evolving technology needs and leverage new technology benefits. This technology refresh
creates a huge amount of electronic waste (or e-waste) requiring special disposal. These disposal costs are
recurring in nature and contribute to the overall cost of desktop ownership and operation.
Desktops today also need to be available and running round the clock. Given the fact that a single
desktop per user consumes significant power, when scaled-up to tens of thousands of desktops, power
consumption can drastically affect the overall IT budget and future cost-control strategies.
Increasing costs of desktop ownership and high energy demands are driving organizations to explore
efficient IT strategies to reduce their carbon footprint and optimally leverage shrinking natural resources.
In the article, ‘Harnessing Green IT: Principles and Practices’, San Murugesan defines the field of green
computing as "the study and practice of designing, manufacturing, using and disposing of computers,
servers and associated subsystems such as monitors, printers, storage devices and networking and
communications systems efficiently and effectively with minimal or no impact on the environment.”
Green desktops are aimed at maximizing energy efficiency and reducing the generation of e-waste
through effective utilization of desktop computing resources such as CPU, memory and hard drives.
Traditional Green Desktops
Introduction
Traditional approach to green desktops was confined to the Corporate Social Responsibility (CSR)
initiatives of companies. Traditional approaches involved user awareness sessions on the implications of
high carbon footprint and ways to reduce desktop power consumption.
Approach Analysis
As a preliminary step to environment conservation, users were requested to switch off their monitors, and
keep their computers in sleep/stand-by/hibernate mode when not in use. However, the success of these
initiatives was dependent on the users’ discretion and their sensitivity to the environment. Even an
environment sensitive user could, at times, forget to adopt these practices, rendering the approach
ineffective and inefficient.
4
Hardware Original Equipment Manufacturers (OEMs) have also taken on a ‘green’ initiative to create
energy efficient desktops and improve the disposal of e-waste from their products. The Environment
Protection Agency (EPA) conceived the Energy Star Program to certify products based on their electricity
consumption. However, these initiatives alone are not sufficient to address the pressing issue of the
carbon footprint being generated by the organizations.
With operating systems evolving over time, power management settings to automatically switch off or
bring the idle computer to stand-by/sleep mode came into being. Such automatic power management is
often not recommended because desktop backup and maintenance activities are often scheduled during
off-peak hours when desktops are not being used. This also reduces the overall end-user experience as
desktops need to be rebooted at the start of each day and users have to wait for logon scripts to execute
and the desktop to be ready for use.
Another technique often adopted by organizations is to allocate one desktop to more than one user
based on the availability. Through this, utilization of existing desktops can be increased, reducing the
need to procure additional desktops. However, in this approach the actual number of desktops in use
remains the same. Also, existing desktops can never utilize 100% of their available resources because at
their peak workload, users may face performance degradation. For realizing real and tangible cost
benefits, increase in desktop utilization should be coupled with the reduction in the actual energy
required to keep the desktops running.
Approach Evolution
Virtualization is fast proving to be the preferred solution for going ‘green’, additionally benefiting
organizations through reduced overall operational expenditure (OPEX) and capital expenditure (CAPEX).
Virtualization reduces the total number of physical servers running in the datacenter by consolidating
multiple virtual servers into one physical server. Thus far, virtualization as an optimization process has
been confined to datacenter strategies with desktops excluded from this process.
Green Desktop Infrastructure
Introduction
Virtualization is fast proving to be the preferred solution for going ‘green’, additionally benefiting
organizations through reduced overall operational expenditure (OPEX) and capital expenditure (CAPEX).
Virtualization reduces the total number of physical servers running in the datacenter by consolidating
multiple virtual servers into one physical server. Thus far, virtualization as an optimization process has
been confined to datacenter strategies with desktops excluded from this process.
Approach Analysis
Desktop virtualization is the process of hosting desktops in a virtualized datacenter and providing virtual
desktops to information workers. Desktop virtualization gives system administrators the ability to host
and manage virtual machines in a centrally located datacenter and the end-user, a full desktop computer
experience. Virtualization helps consolidate desktops on the server hardware and, thus, reduce the overall
5
workspace and power requirements. It also helps in remote access of desktops and in addressing mobility
requirements of the end-users.
Desktop virtualization can be leveraged to integrate different virtualization technology components into
an efficient Virtual Desktop Infrastructure (VDI).
VDI is a variation of the traditional server-based computing (SBC) model where a single operating
system image is shared across multiple users. From the end-user perspective, an SBC model provides a
many-to-one relationship while a VDI works on a one-to-one relationship between end-clients and
operating systems.
Reference Architecture
Green Desktop Infrastructure setup requires integration of multiple software technology components for
end-to-end desktop delivery.
Figure 1: Server-Based Computing
Figure 2: Virtual Desktop Infrastructure
6
Shared storage is a key component of the technology stack - it provides a centralized storage repository
for storing virtual machine images and user data. Centralized storage provides the much needed
consolidation platform for the entire distributed desktop infrastructure. Storage reduction techniques
Figure 3: Green Desktop Technology Stack
such as data de-duplication and thin provisioning reduce the overall storage requirements significantly in
VDI environments. This is possible because the VDI environment consists of multiple images of the same
operating systems on a single shared storage and de-duplication technology is capable of removing
duplicate blocks from the storage. So, there are lesser moving parts involved in data storage providing
huge energy benefits as compared to a similar setup with traditional desktop infrastructure.
The compute platform comprises server infrastructure capable of hosting the virtual environment and
connects to the organizational network. It is used for setting up the hypervisor for hosting the virtual
infrastructure. The hypervisor is responsible for segregating the physical pool of hardware resources and
7
sharing it across the virtual infrastructure. This entire operation is transparent to the virtual machine.
Hypervisors provide huge consolidation ratios, thereby reducing the number of moving hardware parts
significantly. This enables replacement of multiple physical desktops with a single hardware server
thereby improving the overall operational efficiency.
The application virtualization platform helps in rendering the virtualized applications to the end-user
desktops based on user profiling requirements. Applications can be virtualized and made independent of
the underlying hardware and software platform and can be streamed directly to the end-user desktops.
This is an optional component in a typical VDI setup and can be used based on the requirement.
The VDI Connection Broker is a key component, taking care of authentication and authorization of
desktop users and mapping users to their corresponding desktops. It allows for the creation of desktop
pools based on user workload or end-user profiles. Desktops in the pool are pre-configured based on user
requirements and entitled to virtual desktops. The desktop connection broker is tightly integrated with
the Active Directory allowing seamless user and desktop management.
From the end-user perspective, the virtual machines are accessible from a variety of end-client devices
such as thin clients, traditional or refurbished desktop PCs or mobile and handheld devices. The solution
allows for a Bring-Your-Own-PC (BYOP) model where users can bring any end-user devices and get their
personalized virtual desktops streamed and loaded to their devices.
Desktops created from a VDI solution can either be persistent or non-persistent. Non-persistent desktops
are destroyed at the end of the user session, thereby providing great physical resource sharing. This is
possible because only the desktops that are being used by users are available and contributing to the
physical resource consumption. This model improves the consolidation ratio of virtual desktops to
physical servers even more significantly.
Test Results and Business Benefits
A proof-of-concept (PoC) on VDI was conducted at the TCS NetApp Solutions Lab to assess the amount of
savings that can be achieved by replacing physical desktops with virtual desktops. We conducted the PoC
on VMware VDI technology components using NetApp storage controllers.
We also conducted scalability tests to determine the number of Virtual Machines (VMs) (with medium
load and Win 7 as Guest OS) that can be used on an ESX host without noticeable system performance
degradation.
These tests were performed on a Dell 2950 series server with two quad core CPUs (8 * 2.66 GHz) and an 8
GB RAM hosting VMware ESX server with 75 virtual machines on a 1 Gigabit network. The datastores for
the virtual machines were created on the iSCSI LUNs provisioned through NetApp FAS3140 Storage
System.
We started the virtual machines on the ESX host in batches of five VMs at a time and captured the
corresponding ESX host performance metrics (CPU and Memory) in the graphs shown in Figures 4 and 5
The performance charts provide key insights into consolidation ratios that can be achieved practically.
The VDI was easily able to scale-up to 45 virtual desktops (using Windows 7 machines). At the threshold
limit, the server CPU utilization was only near 50% while memory became a bottleneck.
8
Figure 4: Host CPU Performance Chart
Figure 5: Host Memory Performance Chart
9
These results indicate that a physical server with 8GB Memory and 8 CPU cores can host around 45 virtual
desktops. Assuming an average PC power consumption of 190 Watts and an average 8 core CPU power
consumption of 450 Watts, the amount of power savings for 1 to 10000 virtual desktops is highlighted in
Figure 6.
Figure 6: Power Savings in Virtual Desktops
As per calculations, the amount of power savings for 10000 desktops can be a significant 16 GWh per year.
The high-level assumptions for these calculations are:
n
Average Cooling Power Required = Average Power Consumed
n
Average PC Power Consumption = 450 W
n
Average Thin Client Power Consumption = 50 W
n
Average Server Power Consumption = 450 W
n
Average Storage Power Consumption = 1000 W per TB
n
Average hard disk size in traditional desktop = 150 GB
10
If we plot these metrics on a chart, it can be observed from the calculations that the amount of savings
increases as the number of virtual desktops increase. So, the organic growth for an organization can, in
fact, lead to additional savings on power and cooling without compromising the end-users’ desktop
experience.
Figure 7: Annual Power Saving Metrics
If we analyze the environmental impact of the power savings achieved through desktop virtualization,
significant contribution towards the environment is evident from the metrics and charts in Figures 8 and
9. These metrics are under the assumption that every kWh of power emits 0.6 kg of carbon dioxide (CO2)
and on an average 202 kg of CO2 is absorbed by a single tree.
11
Figure 8: Annual CO2 Emission Reductions Metrics
Figure 9: CO2 Emission Reduction Equivalent by Planting Trees
12
Conclusion
The proliferation of desktops and the escalating desktop management costs are a cause for concern for
several organizations. Power and cooling costs, often ignored by organizations, are significant
contributors to the escalating costs of desktop ownership. Power and cooling cost savings that were once
part of Green IT initiatives are now regarded as strategic cost control initiatives.
The traditional green desktops only offer power management techniques and are a limited contribution
to Green IT initiatives by hardware OEMs.
Virtualization is an effective technique to reduce the overall cost of ownership as well as the carbon
footprint of an organization. This technique has often been confined to servers alone while desktops have
been excluded from this organizational initiative.
Desktop virtualization is the mechanism of transforming desktops from distributed silos to a centralized
pool of virtual resources hosted within the secure premises of the datacenter. This has inherent
operational benefits and also brings in the added advantage of reduced power and cooling costs for the
desktop infrastructure.
From the results of tests conducted in our lab, it was observed that high consolidation ratios of virtual
desktops on physical servers can result in huge power savings and help in effectively reducing
operational costs and the overall carbon footprint of an organization.
References
[1] Green Grid, http://www.thegreengrid.org/
[2] VMware, http://www.vmware.com
[3] Wikipedia, www.wikipedia.org
[4] TCS NetApp Solutions Lab PoC Reports
[5]TCS VDI Brochure
Vmware is a registered trademark of VMware Inc. | Dell is a registered trademark of Dell Inc. | NetApp is a registered trademark of NetApp Inc.
13
Contact
For more information about TCS’ consulting services, contact [email protected]
Subscribe to TCS White Papers
TCS.com RSS: http://www.tcs.com/rss_feeds/Pages/feed.aspx?f=w
Feedburner: http://feeds2.feedburner.com/tcswhitepapers
About Tata Consultancy Services (TCS)
Tata Consultancy Services is an IT services, consulting and business solutions organization that
delivers real results to global business, ensuring a level of certainty no other firm can match.
TCS offers a consulting-led, integrated portfolio of IT and IT-enabled infrastructure, engineering
and assurance services. This is delivered through its unique Global Network Delivery ModelTM,
recognized as the benchmark of excellence in software development. A part of the Tata Group,
India’s largest industrial conglomerate, TCS has a global footprint and is listed on the National
Stock Exchange and Bombay Stock Exchange in India.
IT Services
Business Solutions
Outsourcing
All content / information present here is the exclusive property of Tata Consultancy Services Limited (TCS). The content / information contained here is
correct at the time of publishing. No material from here may be copied, modified, reproduced, republished, uploaded, transmitted, posted or distributed in
any form without prior written permission from TCS. Unauthorized use of the content / information appearing here may violate copyright, trademark and
other applicable laws, and could result in criminal or civil penalties. Copyright © 2013 Tata Consultancy Services Limited
TCS Design Services I M I 03 I 13
For more information, visit us at www.tcs.com